Replace homeowners insurance after a nonrenewal or in a hard market
The nonrenewal reason is identified and, where possible, cured; errors on the property’s CLUE and inspection reports are corrected; the market is worked in the right order — admitted carriers, then surplus lines, then the state FAIR plan with a difference-in-conditions wrap — and a policy is bound with adequate replacement cost, the right deductibles, and a documented mitigation discount, with no lapse that lets a mortgage servicer force-place coverage.
Free preview: 3 of 20 steps
Work through them in the real run view, exactly as a buyer does. No account, no payment, nothing saved.
3 free unlocks per month — yours to keep forever
No account needed — nothing is saved.
Included with every copy
- Your own copy — keep it forever
- Gets better over time — free updates included
- Run it on web and mobile
- Invite a partner to go through it with you — you share the same progress
- Make it your own — a private copy you can edit to fit your situation
- The playbook's community — ask questions, get additions, and see how other buyers improve it, right on the step
Who it's for
Homeowners in wildfire, wind, hail, and flood-exposed markets who received a nonrenewal notice or a doubled premium, including those whose mortgage servicer is threatening force-placed coverage.
About this playbook
A nonrenewal notice, or a premium that doubled overnight, is not the end of your options — and lender-placed coverage is not your only outcome. This guide takes you through the only sequence that works in a hard market: find out exactly why the insurer acted and fix what is fixable, pull and correct the loss-history reports that follow the property, then shop in the order the market demands — admitted carriers first, surplus lines second, and the state FAIR plan as the backstop, closed with a difference-in-conditions wrap that covers its gaps. You compare quotes on identical coverage, right-size the deductible, and bind a policy that overlaps the old one with no gap. Most of the path is paperwork, phone calls, and waiting on quotes; one phase asks for a few hours of physical work such as brush clearance or a roof certification. It does not cover claims adjusting, mortgage refinancing, or anything beyond getting and keeping an insurable policy through the next renewal cycle.
What you'll do, step by stepFree preview
Only a sample is open: 3 of 20 steps can be read in full. The rest unlock when you buy.
Phase 1: Diagnose the nonrenewal
5 stepsPhase 2: Cure what the insurer will not overlook
5 stepsPhase 3: Work the market in the right order
5 stepsPhase 4: Compare, bind, and protect the policy
5 steps
Details
What you need first
A current homeowners policy or a recent nonrenewal or cancellation notice, plus the declarations page of the expiring policy. The mortgage servicer’s contact details for escrow matters and any force-placed notices. A few hours for property work if mitigation is required — brush clearance, small repairs, or an inspection visit. Because notice periods, FAIR plan rules, and mitigation programs differ by state, verify the specifics for your state as you go.
Tags
Common questions
About the creator
Similar playbooks
